The costliest first-time buyer mistakes to avoid in Greater Boston are touring before pre-approval with the right lender, misreading first-time-buyer and asset rules, underestimating closing and ownership costs, waiving protections you don’t understand, and assuming one town’s assistance rules apply everywhere.

First-Time Buyer Mistakes to Avoid in Greater Boston

What first-time buyer mistakes should you avoid in Greater Boston?

The costliest mistakes to avoid in Greater Boston are touring seriously before you have a pre-approval from the right lender, misreading first-time-buyer and asset rules, underestimating closing and ownership costs, waiving contract protections you don’t fully understand, and assuming one town’s assistance rules apply to the next. Every one of them is fixable before you write an offer, which is why the order you do things in matters as much as the list itself.

Key Takeaways

  • Recent local market data for Arlington shows a median sale price of $1,100,000 and a median of 56 days on market over roughly the last 90 days, so a budgeting or offer mistake carries real dollars.
  • Boston’s First-Time Homebuyer Program requires a CHAPA-approved Homebuying 101 course and a pre-approval from a participating lender before you apply.
  • Boston’s program materials set household income below 135% of area median income and household assets below $100,000, and they count gift funds, cryptocurrency, cash-app balances, and real-estate equity as assets.
  • The MassHousing assistance of up to $25,000 at 0% interest was tied to mortgage locks from April 27 through July 31, 2026, so that window has closed.
  • Income, asset, education, and lender rules differ by program and by municipality, so Boston’s requirements should never be assumed in Cambridge, Somerville, Quincy, or anywhere else.

I’ve spent more than 30 years helping buyers in Arlington, Belmont, Watertown, Waltham, Cambridge, Lexington, Winchester, and Medford, and the same handful of mistakes keeps costing people money and time. Here’s how I’d help you sidestep them.

Why is shopping before pre-approval one of the costliest mistakes?

Because a pre-approval from the wrong lender can leave you unable to use the assistance you were counting on, and touring without a real budget has you falling for homes you can’t finance. In a market where the typical Arlington home spent a median of 56 days on market in recent local data, you have time to do this in the right order. You don’t need to rush in.

Boston’s city program requires a first-mortgage pre-approval from a participating lender, and the mortgage has to comply with applicable Fannie Mae general loan limits, according to the City of Boston First-Time Homebuyer Program. A general pre-approval from a lender that doesn’t participate may not satisfy the program at all.

For Boston’s program, the practical sequence looks like this:

  1. Confirm you qualify as a first-time buyer.
  2. Review your household income and assets against the program limits.
  3. Complete an accepted Homebuying 101 course.
  4. Get pre-approved by a participating lender.
  5. Evaluate properties, then submit the program application.

When you talk to a lender, ask which assistance programs they’re approved to originate and whether the property type you’re considering (a condo versus a two-family, for example) qualifies. I’d rather you spend a couple of weeks getting this right than rush into an offer on a house your financing can’t support. Preparation beats speed here.

What counts as a first-time buyer in Boston?

Boston generally defines a first-time buyer as someone who hasn’t owned property during the previous three years, with limited exceptions, per the city’s program page. That means “first-time” does not always mean “never owned.” If you owned a home years ago, don’t rule yourself out, and don’t assume you qualify either. Verify with the administering office before you rely on it.

How can your assets disqualify you?

Boston’s application materials define assets broadly, and household assets must be below $100,000. The application checklist counts bank and investment accounts, cryptocurrency, cash-app balances, gift funds, gifts of equity, and real-estate equity. It lists specified exceptions such as approved retirement funds, Roth IRAs, and college-savings plans.

The mistake I see is treating assets only as a down-payment question. Moving money between accounts or accepting family help without documenting it can create an eligibility or underwriting problem. Sort out the paper trail with your lender before you shop, not after you’re under contract.

What are Boston’s first-time buyer requirements for assistance?

To use Boston’s city program, you need first-time-buyer status under the three-year rule, a CHAPA-approved Homebuying 101 course, a pre-approval from a participating lender, household income below 135% of area median income, and household assets below $100,000. Other programs stack their own rules on top, and they’re not interchangeable.

ProgramKey requirementsWorth knowing
Boston First-Time Homebuyer ProgramThree-year lookback; CHAPA-approved Homebuying 101; participating-lender pre-approval; income below 135% of area median income; assets below $100,000Mortgage must comply with applicable Fannie Mae general loan limits
BHA First Home ProgramFor eligible BHA residents: two years of consistent employment, at least $4,000 in savings, credit score above 650, no household ownership in the previous three years, course completed within the previous three yearsSeparate from the city program
Boston Homes LotteryIncome limits for the property; pre-approval for the property type and price; sufficient savings; first-time-buyer, education, and household-size requirementsRequirements are property-specific
MassHousing 2026 enhancementUp to $25,000 at 0% interest with deferred repayment; income up to 135% of area median income; Massachusetts primary residence; MassHousing mortgage through a partner lenderAnnounced for mortgage locks April 27 through July 31, 2026, so the window has closed

What credit score do you need?

There’s no single number. Boston’s general program materials emphasize program eligibility and participating-lender underwriting rather than publishing one universal credit-score threshold. The BHA program, by contrast, lists a score above 650 in its program requirements. Don’t apply the BHA threshold to every Boston or Massachusetts program, and ask your lender what their underwriting requires for the loan you want.

Which costs and contract protections do first-time buyers misjudge?

They misjudge the costs that sit on top of the purchase price, and they give up protections to make an offer look stronger. Both are among the first-time buyer mistakes I most want you to avoid in Greater Boston, because they show up after you’ve committed.

What closing and ownership costs should you plan for?

Plan for categories rather than one number, because the amounts depend on the property, the loan, and the town. I won’t hand you a figure that could be wrong for your home. Instead, get written numbers for each of these:

  • Lender charges and prepaid items tied to your specific loan
  • Title insurance, recording, and closing agent fees handled at closing
  • Property taxes, which are set by the municipality and vary from town to town
  • Homeowners insurance, quoted for the actual property
  • Condo fees and special assessments, if you’re buying a condo
  • Maintenance and replacement costs, especially heating systems, roofs, and older mechanicals

Your lender, an insurer, the condo association, and the closing agent can each give you property-specific figures. Price points also vary widely across the towns I work in, which changes every one of these line items. Recent local data for Arlington shows 65 active listings, 33 new listings in the last 30 days, and 95 homes sold over roughly 90 days.

Source: aggregated public listing data, trailing 90 days, as of October 2026.
AreaMedian Sale PriceMedian Days on Market
Arlington$1,100,00056
Belmont$1,475,00049
Watertown$769,00065
Waltham$810,00050
Cambridge$1,047,50055
Lexington$1,555,00054
Winchester$1,700,00061
Medford$841,94457

These are area-level medians. An individual home’s value depends on condition, street, build year, and timing, which is why I build a budget around the specific properties you’re considering.

What happens when you waive protections to win?

Waiving an inspection, financing, or appraisal protection can leave you carrying risk you never priced in. What each one does depends on the wording of your contract, so don’t give any of them up until you know exactly what you’d be exposed to if the deal went sideways.

The appraisal is a good example. If a home comes in below the purchase price, a buyer who waived protections may have to cover the gap or lose leverage. I break that scenario down in What Happens if a Home Appraises Below the Purchase Price?. A strong offer and a protected offer aren’t opposites, but the right balance depends on the home, your lender, and your savings. This is the kind of decision where having a buyer’s agent in your corner pays for itself, and I walk my clients through each protection before we write an offer.

What should you avoid in Greater Boston when assistance rules change by town?

Avoid assuming Boston’s income, asset, education, lender, and property rules apply in Cambridge, Somerville, Quincy, Brookline, or the towns around them. Each municipality that offers assistance sets its own terms, and some buyers only find out after they’ve fallen for a home that doesn’t fit.

Here’s how I’d check any town’s program:

  1. Identify which municipality or agency actually administers the assistance.
  2. Get its current application checklist, not a summary from a third-party site.
  3. Confirm what form the help takes: a grant, deferred loan, forgivable loan, lottery-linked benefit, or lender-based product.
  4. Ask your lender whether they’re approved to originate it and whether your target property type qualifies.

What about the MassHousing $25,000 assistance?

It was a time-limited opportunity. The state announced up to $25,000 at 0% interest with deferred repayment, usable for a down payment, closing costs, upfront mortgage insurance, or a permanent rate buydown. It applied to mortgage locks from April 27 through July 31, 2026, per the official announcement, so that window is behind us. MassHousing assistance generally requires a MassHousing mortgage through a partner lender, as described on the state’s Unlocking Homeownership page. Ask a lender what MassHousing offers today before you plan around any past headline.

For more on how buyers are adjusting their search this year, read The New Starter Home: How First-Time Buyers Are Adapting in 2026.

Don’t take my word or a program page’s word for your own eligibility. Your income, assets, property type, and town all change the answer, and the only way to know is to run your numbers with someone who knows these programs and this market.

Read what past clients say about working with me on Google.

FAQ

Do I need a mortgage pre-approval before I start looking at homes in Boston?

Yes, get one before you tour seriously. Boston’s First-Time Homebuyer Program requires a pre-approval from a participating lender before you apply, and a pre-approval from a lender that doesn’t participate may not count. Start with the lender conversation so your budget and program eligibility are settled before you fall for a property.

What does Boston consider a first-time homebuyer, and can I qualify if I owned a home years ago?

Boston generally treats you as a first-time buyer if you haven’t owned property during the previous three years, with limited exceptions. So owning a home longer ago than that may not disqualify you. Confirm the details and any documentation with the administering office before you rely on the rule.

Can gift money, retirement accounts, cryptocurrency, or cash-app balances affect eligibility?

Yes, they can. Boston’s application checklist counts gift funds, gifts of equity, cryptocurrency, cash-app funds, investment accounts, and real-estate equity toward the asset limit, while listing exceptions such as approved retirement funds, Roth IRAs, and college-savings plans. Document everything with your lender before moving money around.

Does a Boston first-time-buyer program require me to use a specific lender?

Yes, Boston’s program requires a participating lender. MassHousing assistance similarly requires a MassHousing mortgage through a partner lender. Ask any lender which programs they’re approved to originate before you pay for or rely on a pre-approval.

Are income and asset limits the same in every Greater Boston municipality?

No, don’t assume they are. Boston’s limits (income below 135% of area median income and assets below $100,000) apply to Boston’s program, and other municipalities and programs set their own terms. Get the current checklist from whichever municipality or agency administers the assistance you want to use.

The mistakes to avoid in Greater Boston almost always come down to doing things out of order or assuming a rule travels from one program or town to another. If you want to know where you stand, find out the value of your home if you already own, or search for homes once your financing is lined up. Then call or text me at 781-454-9900 and we’ll build your plan before you make an offer.

About Bob Bittelari

Bob Bittelari has more than 30 years of experience helping buyers and sellers across Greater Boston, and he was selected into the Century 21 Master’s Hall of Fame in 1999. He joined Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Commonwealth Real Estate in July 2019, where he has earned the Chairman’s Circle distinction. A Past President of the Greater Boston Real Estate Board’s local council and a longtime Arlington Little League and Arlington Youth Hockey coach, Bob takes the time to listen, educate, and give tailored advice. Call or text him at 781-454-9900.

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Commonwealth Real Estate · 781-454-9900

Equal Housing Opportunity. Bob Bittelari is a licensed Massachusetts real estate salesperson regulated by the Massachusetts Board of Registration of Real Estate Brokers and Salespersons. This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice; confirm your own numbers with your closing agent, tax advisor, or lender.